by Troppo » Fri Feb 15, 2013 8:42 am
Shaun, I haven't answered your question but here's my limited experience with two types of dinghies.
I have a plastic sit-on-top (SOT) kayak that I tied on deck the port side. The problem was that the furler line sometimes got stuck on it. While I could not go along the port side with the kayak there, it was ok just going to the bow via the starboard side. The kayak is low to the water and so I found it awkward at times getting up from it into Windchaser, that ladder on the stern was essential. It was extremely easy to deploy and recover from the deck as it simply slipped under the safety wires. Just had to remember to hold tightly to the line as it would shoot off quite quickly. With cartage, one time I carried 2x 20 litre fuel tanks on it which was a bit tricky when coming back with them full and then hefting the tanks up on deck. Overall, I was happy enough with my plastic SOT as it had, for one person, reasonable carrying capacity, easy to deploy and recover from deck, easy and fun to paddle. On the negative, often had a wet bum, ladder essential for ease of getting up and down, was a bit of a problem with the jib, needed to carry my camera etc in a waterproof bag, only big enough for one.
I prefer not to use the SOT on the Fitzroy River and have bought an aluminium dinghy, 11 foot, not a punt, pointed bow. The benefits include; easy to climb out of the dinghy into Windchaser (I tie up alongside using 2 ropes), handles the river chop no problems, safely carries heaps of boat gear and easy to unload into Windchaser, easy to row, can carry a passenger, I remain dry, makes me feel a bit more secure since the river has crocs. The negatives include having to tow it since no room on deck, heavier to handle on shore such as pulling it up a sandbank or taking it home, the aluminium gets burny to touch in hot summer sun.